How to Navigate ‘Insanity Waves’ in Canadian Microcap Stocks on the TSX Venture and CSE

The TSX Venture Exchange (TSXV) and Canadian Securities Exchange (CSE) are fertile grounds for speculation and hype, where one or two themes often dominate at a time. From gold rushes to lithium booms to AI buzz and now crypto euphoria, these “insanity waves” can propel microcap stocks to astonishing heights—usually leaving retail investors holding the bag. These exchanges are driven by brokers and promoters who get in early, riding the wave on cheap shares and exiting at peak prices, often before institutional investors validate the trend. Navigating these volatile markets requires vigilance, strategy, and an understanding of the dynamics at play.

Here’s how to make sense of these speculative cycles and position yourself wisely.

1. Recognize the Hype Cycle in Canadian Microcaps

Canadian microcaps listed on the TSXV and CSE are notorious for their hype-driven cycles. On these exchanges, the crowd tends to latch onto one or two hot themes at a time. Understanding the five stages of a hype cycle can help you avoid buying into the frenzy and identify whether a wave has legs.

Stage 1: Innovation Trigger
A breakthrough or announcement sparks initial interest. It could be a new lithium discovery or a gold deposit in a prolific mining region. A $5M market cap company can jump to $50M overnight, and share prices may 10x as speculative money rushes in.

Stage 2: Copycat Deals
Once a few companies see their share prices soar on news of entering a hot sector, Howe and Bay Street promoters and brokers flood the market with copycat deals. Many of these companies initially lack operational substance, aiming only to capitalize on the hype by issuing flashy press releases.

Stage 3: Peak of Inflated Expectations
Retail investors pile in as media coverage and FOMO (fear of missing out) reach a fever pitch. Stock prices reach unsustainable levels, driven more by sentiment than fundamentals.

Stage 4: Trough of Disillusionment
Reality sets in. Many of the copycat deals collapse as investors realize they lack meaningful assets or execution capability. Stock prices plummet, leaving retail investors to bear the losses.

Stage 5: Plateau of Productivity
Only the strongest companies with real operational plans and disciplined execution remain. These survivors stabilize and attract institutional investors, offering long-term opportunities for discerning investors.

One key sign that a wave may some legs is institutional validation. If brokerages and institutional investors begin funding companies in the sector at higher valuations, the trend may last longer. If they avoid funding altogether, the wave will collapse.

2. Do Your Due Diligence Beyond the Buzz

The TSXV and CSE are fertile ground for speculative plays, but not every company is created equal. Dig deeper to separate companies with substance from those riding the wave for a quick pump.

Evaluate Management: Are the leaders experienced and credible? Do they have a track record of success? Have they been able to deliver sustainable longer-term wins for investors? Execution is critical, especially in sectors prone to hype. Avoid companies led by serial promoters, raising small amounts of capital without tangible results and no budgets outside of marketing to advance an actual business.

Assess Financial Health: Does the company have the capital to deliver on its promises? Companies relying heavily on dilutive financings or marketing are at greater risk of failure.

Validate Their Assets: In resource-heavy sectors like mining, ensure the company’s claims are backed by verifiable data. Look for NI 43-101 reports or equivalent certifications for validation. Outside of the resource sector, does an announced acquisition lead to a business that has operated prior to the sector becoming hot. Have BAR’s been filed, audits completed?

Examine the Cap Table and Recent Transactions: A company’s capitalization table can reveal a lot about its structure and motivations. Look for recent low-priced share issuances, exchanges, or debt conversions - particularly those involving related parties or insider groups. Often, a new promote is seeded with cheap shares allocated to a group of promoters and brokers who fund the initial leg of the hype. These participants stand to benefit significantly from even modest increases in the stock price, often exiting before retail investors realize what’s happening. Related-party transactions should also be scrutinized to assess whether insiders are prioritizing their interests over those of shareholders. A heavily tilted cap table can signal a stock structured more for promotion than for long-term value creation. You can’t defy gravity for long. Average prices paid for shares will give an indication to the likely future price the shares will trade at.

Follow the Rule - Commodity Prices Must Be Rising: For commodity-related deals, the golden rule is simple: share prices only climb if the underlying commodity price is going up. It's an escalator on the way up and an elevator on the way down. For example, lithium stocks soared when battery-grade spot prices surged a few years ago, but when prices began to drop due to increased supply and uneconomic operations shutting down, investor enthusiasm evaporated.

Uranium has followed similar cycles, with its 2006-2007 bull run and a resurgence in recent years. However, in 2024, uranium investors have faced challenges as both contract and spot prices have pulled back.

If the underlying commodity price starts to decline consistently over a few weeks or months, it's often a sign that it's time to reduce exposure and lock in some gains. Markets can turn quickly, and even fundamentally sound companies can see their share prices plummet alongside the commodity price. Always keep an eye on macro trends, supply-demand dynamics, analyst price target downgrades and, price charts for the underlying commodity.

By adhering to these principles, you'll be better positioned to navigate the speculative nature of commodity-driven microcaps and avoid being caught in the inevitable downturns.

3. Set a Realistic Entry and Exit Strategy

Timing is crucial when investing in speculative Canadian microcaps. Brokers and insiders often get in early and exit at inflated prices, leaving retail investors exposed to downside risk. Avoid becoming part of the crowd rushing in late.

Entry: Enter early in the Innovation Trigger stage, when valuations are still reasonable (under $25M market cap is a good rule of thumb). If you’re late to the wave, wait for the Trough to find opportunities among survivors.

Exit: Set clear profit targets and stick to them. Many investors hold out for higher gains and end up riding the wave back down. Don’t be afraid to lock in profits.

4. Understand the Role of Brokers and Promoters

On the TSXV and CSE, brokers and promoters play a significant role in driving hype. They often secure cheap financing rounds before the broader market takes notice. Retail investors should be cautious when these players dominate a deal, as their interests are often misaligned with long-term shareholders.

Watch for Funding Rounds: If a company is funded by major broker-dealers or attracts institutional investment, it’s a positive sign of validation. Avoid companies relying solely on retail financings or small private placements from unknown backers.

Monitor Insider Activity: Insider buying is a strong vote of confidence, while significant insider selling can be a red flag—especially during the Peak of Inflated Expectations stage.

5. Focus on Fundamentals Over Fads

In the chaos of an insanity wave, it’s easy to overlook fundamentals. However, the companies that survive and thrive are those with solid business models, real assets, and disciplined management.

Revenue and Profitability: Is the company generating revenue or on a clear path to doing so? In resource deals, do they have an actual NI 43-101 resource calculation – a deposit? Promises alone don’t pay the bills.

Sustainable Growth: Can the company scale without burning through its cash reserves? Excessive reliance on dilutive financing is a warning sign.

Transparency: Look for companies with detailed and transparent reporting. Those that over-promise and under-deliver falter.

6. Tune Out the Noise

Speculation in Canadian microcaps is fueled by news releases, message boards, and media coverage. Avoid being swayed by the constant noise and focus on the metrics and fundamentals that matter. A disciplined dual-pronged, short-term and long-term approach will serve you better than chasing every rumor.

In Summary: Playing It Smart on the TSXV and CSE

The TSXV and CSE are exciting but treacherous markets where hype cycles often dominate, and retail investors can sometimes bear the brunt of the fallout. However, these exchanges also offer the potential for tremendous gains and the discovery of real, innovative companies. Amid the speculation and noise, the entrepreneurial spirit is alive and well, with founders leveraging these markets to fund ambitious ventures and create meaningful value. By recognizing the stages of a hype cycle, performing thorough due diligence, and setting clear strategies, you can navigate these waves with confidence. Pay close attention to whether institutional investors validate a trend and always prioritize fundamentals over fads. With a strategic approach, you can identify opportunities to capitalize on the highs while mitigating risks. These markets may be risky, but they also hold the promise of uncovering the next big success story.

See Other Interviews

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Don't miss any of our episodes and microcap deep dives.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.